Fake Review Attack: Exactly What to Do When Competitors Target Your Business

In today’s digital landscape, your business’s online reputation can make or break your bottom line. In fact, a hotel with a rating of just 3.9 stars stands to lose an astonishing $97,588 each month in revenue. The stakes are even higher when it comes to restaurants; those rated at 3.7 stars can forfeit approximately $47,000 monthly. With 33% of consumers bypassing businesses rated below 4.0 stars, and 89% reading reviews before making decisions, the impact of fake reviews cannot be underestimated.

When competitors launch a coordinated fake review attack, it can feel like a punch to the gut. But knowing how to respond can make a significant difference. This guide will walk you through a comprehensive recovery plan to address fake review attacks and reclaim your reputation.

Step 1: Detect the Fake Review Attack

The first step in recovery is identifying that a fake review attack is occurring. Look for sudden spikes in review volume, especially if they coincide with a drop in your ratings. Pay attention to reviewer profiles; if you see multiple reviews from similar accounts with generic names or lacking purchase histories, it’s a strong indicator of a coordinated attack.

Use your review management tools to track changes in your ratings. If you notice a pattern, document everything. This documentation will be crucial for the next steps in your recovery.

Step 2: Document Everything

Once you suspect a fake review attack, start documenting every detail. Take screenshots of all reviews, noting dates, reviewer names, and content. Keep a record of any unusual activity, including the timing of when the reviews appear and any connections to your competitors.

This documentation will help you build a case if you need to escalate the issue, whether to review platforms or legal authorities. Make sure to include any evidence that ties these reviews back to specific competitors, if possible.

Step 3: Flag the Reviews

After you’ve documented the fake reviews, your next step is to flag them on the platforms where they appear. Most review sites have a process for reporting spam or fake reviews. Follow the specific guidelines for each platform, providing the evidence you’ve collected.

For example, Google allows businesses to report reviews that violate their policies. Use the information you’ve gathered to clearly outline why these reviews are fraudulent. Be persistent; it may take several attempts to get a response.

Step 4: Create an Emergency Response Plan

In the midst of a fake review attack, it’s critical to have an emergency response plan in place. Your plan should include immediate actions to take, such as responding to negative reviews professionally and calmly, even if they are fake.

Consider drafting template responses that you can customize based on the review content. This not only helps in maintaining a professional image but also shows potential customers that you are engaged and care about feedback.

Step 5: Utilize Legal Options

If you can identify the competitor behind the fake reviews, you may have legal options available. A cease and desist letter can be an effective tool, warning the offending party to stop their actions or face legal consequences. Consult with a legal professional to draft this letter appropriately.

In some cases, you may also consider filing a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). This is especially pertinent if the fake reviews are part of a broader deceptive practice by your competitors.

Step 6: Monitor Your Reviews in Real-Time

Implementing a real-time monitoring system can help you stay ahead of potential fake review attacks. Tools like SCORIXA provide real-time detection of new reviews as they post. This ensures that you can respond quickly to any negative feedback before it escalates.

For instance, one restaurant chain using SCORIXA detected 47 fake reviews within just six hours. By reacting swiftly, they were able to mitigate damage and maintain their reputation.

Step 7: Engage with Your Customers

Rebuilding your reputation after a fake review attack involves engaging with your genuine customers. Encourage them to leave positive reviews by providing excellent service and incentivizing feedback, such as through email campaigns or loyalty programs.

Remember, responding to all reviews — both positive and negative — can lead to an average increase of 12% in the number of reviews you receive. Your genuine customers can help drown out the noise of the fake reviews.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Ignoring Fake Reviews

Failing to act on fake reviews can have dire consequences for your business. Ignoring them sends a message that you don’t care about your reputation. Addressing them head-on is key.

2. Responding Emotionally

While it’s natural to feel defensive, responding emotionally can worsen the situation. Keep your responses professional and calm, irrespective of the review content.

3. Not Documenting Evidence

Without proper documentation, you risk losing your case when reporting fake reviews. Always gather evidence as soon as you suspect a coordinated attack.

4. Delaying Action

Time is of the essence when dealing with fake reviews. The longer you wait, the more damage can be done to your reputation. Act quickly and decisively.

5. Overlooking Real Customers

Focusing solely on negative reviews can lead you to overlook your loyal customers. Engage with them and encourage positive feedback to counterbalance any damage done.

6. Neglecting to Use Technology

In today’s fast-paced environment, relying solely on manual tracking can be inefficient. Invest in a reputation management platform like SCORIXA to automate monitoring and responses.

Take Control of Your Reviews — For Free

Every day your competitors are monitoring and responding to reviews. SCORIXA shows you exactly how much revenue your current Google rating is costing you, monitors every new review the moment it posts, and suggests AI-powered responses in seconds.

Start your free SCORIXA account →

No credit card required. Setup takes under 3 minutes.